• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Mommy Made That
  • Crafts
    • Templates
  • Printables
    • Coloring Pages
    • Learning
  • Holidays
  • Guides
  • Shop
  • Recipes
menu icon
go to homepage
  • Crafts
    • Templates
  • Printables
    • Coloring Pages
    • Learning
  • Holidays
  • Guides
  • Shop
  • Recipes
search icon
Homepage link
  • Crafts
    • Templates
  • Printables
    • Coloring Pages
    • Learning
  • Holidays
  • Guides
  • Shop
  • Recipes
×

Home » Recipes

Mr. & Mrs. Potato Head Toy Story Cookies

Published: Mar 14, 2019 · Modified: Aug 17, 2022 by Molly · This post may contain affiliate links.

Sharing is caring!

86 shares
  • Share

Toy story cookie ideas! These potato heads cookies are too cute!

Toy Story is one of those movies that has just dragged out across generations, yet still seems young, fresh and fun.

Especially with the new movie coming out!

If your looking for Toy Story party ideas, here is a great tutorial on these adorable Mr. potato head cookies.

All through these cookies look complicated, they are really just sugar cookies, decorated with frosting, fondant, food coloring gel and (optional) candies. 

Toy story cookie ideas! These potato heads cookies are too cute!

Table of Contents

  • Mr. & Mrs. Potato Head Toy Story Cookies
  • Step 1: Make your Sugar Cookies
  • Step 2: Frost your Cookies
  • Step 3: Add Eyes to Mr. Potato Head
  • Step 4: Make your Fondant Noses
  • Step 5: Place Ears
  • Step 6: Add a Moustache and Lips to Mr. Potato Head
  • Step 7: Adding your Eyebrows

Mr. & Mrs. Potato Head Toy Story Cookies

Supplies

  • Favorite sugar cookie recipes, the kind that you can cut out
  • White frosting (this kind makes it super easy)
  • Fondant (In black, pink, orange, red and yellow)
  • Brown food coloring gel
  • Yellow food coloring gel
  • Candy eyes (Or you can use fondant)
  • Candy Mustaches (Or you can use fondant)

 

Step 1: Make your Sugar Cookies

Roll out your sugar cookie dough and cut out egg-shaped cookies. 

Bake your cookies according to the recipe and set aside to cool completely. 

While your cookies are cooling, place your frosting in a bowl and add in your brown and yellow food coloring to make a "Mr. Potato Head" light brown. 

Toy Story cookie ideas. Perfect for a toy story party treat. Potato heads cookies.

 

Step 2: Frost your Cookies

Frost your cookies evenly, leaving room along the edges.

Toy Story cookie ideas. Perfect for a toy story party treat. Potato heads cookies.

 

Step 3: Add Eyes to Mr. Potato Head

Place 2 of your eye candies about ⅓ of the way down you your cookie potato head. 

Toy Story cookie ideas. Perfect for a toy story party treat. Potato heads cookies.

 

Step 4: Make your Fondant Noses

Roll out a piece of your pink fondant into a pyramid for your Mrs. Potato Head cookies. 

Then roll out your orange fondant and create noses for your Mr. Potato Head cookies. 

Toy Story cookie ideas. Perfect for a toy story party treat. Potato heads cookies.

 

Step 5: Place Ears

Now start making pink fondant balls and flatten. Cut them in half and round your edges. These will be your ears for all of your potato heads.

Using tiny pieces of yellow fondant, roll into small balls for Mrs. Potato Heads earings.

Toy Story cookie ideas. Perfect for a toy story party treat. Potato heads cookies.

 

Step 6: Add a Moustache and Lips to Mr. Potato Head

Now place mustache candies on your Mr. Potato Heads in between their nose and mouth.

Now take some medium sized pieces of red fondant and roll out into long snakes. Use these pieces to form the mouths of your Mr. and Mrs. Potato Head cookies. 

For Mrs. Potato Head I like to form lips and for Mr. Potato Head I like to keep his mouth open. To do this, place a thin piece of black fondant behind his mouth to make it look like he's talking. 

It adds a cute personality to the cookies. 

Toy Story cookie ideas. Perfect for a toy story party treat. Potato heads cookies.

 

Step 7: Adding your Eyebrows

Now roll thin pieces of black fondant and place them above your cookies eyes to make eyebrows.

We like using thinner ones for Mrs. Potaoto head, and Thicker ones for Mr. Potato Head. 

Now roll out large pieces of black fondant into a shee. Cut out a hat shape for your Mr. Potato Heads. 

You can ues your white frosting to create a hat for your Mrs. Potato Head cookies. 

Then roll out five small orange balls of fondant and place them to form a flower for her hat. Add a small pink ball to the center to top it off. 

Toy Story cookie ideas. Perfect for a toy story party treat. Potato heads cookies.

Enjoy your super cute Toy Story cookies!

Mr. Potato Head cookies. Great Toy Story Ideas!

More Recipes

  • reindeer cupcake
    Adorable Reindeer Cupcakes (Easy and fun!)
  • non-alcoholic eggnog recipe
    Delicious Non Alcoholic Eggnog
  • halloween oreo spider cookies
    Oreo Spider Cookies
  • halloween rice krispie treats
    15 Amazing Halloween Rice Krispie Treats

Reader Interactions

Share your Ideas! Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

molly mommy made that

Hi, I'm Molly! Welcome to Mommy Made That! Where you'll find family fun and inspiration. Enjoy!!

More about me

Popular

  • Shark activity for preschoolers color sorting game
    Feed the Shark Game with Free Printable
  • pom pom caterpillar craft
    Pom Pom Caterpillar Craft
  • crafts for kids
    100+ Easy Crafts for Kids (Lots of Arts and Craft Ideas!)
  • Easy DIY Felt Gnome Doll
    Adorable No Sew Felt Gnomes

Footer

Categories

Important Links

About
Disclosure
Privacy Policy
Contact

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Photo Use & Linking

You're welcome and encouraged to link to mommymadethat.com. Interested in using a photo for your website? Click here for our policy.

Copyright © 2023 · Mommy Made That