Cute & Super Easy Elmo Cookies

Sharing is caring!

decorated elmo cookies

Here is a simple and easy way to make Elmo cookies in a snap!

Not to mention, these sugar cookies are super cute. 

These would be perfect for an Elmo or Sesame Street themed birthday party or just for a fun rainy day activity with the kids. 

Elmo Cookies

Supplies To Decorate Your Cookies:

  • Large Wilton Candy Eyes 
  • Favorite Premade Sugar Cookies
  • Red Frosting
  • Butter Scotch Hard Candies

Elmo cookie ingredients

How to Make Your Elmo Cookies

Make or buy your favorite sugar cookies. 

Frost each of your cookies with a thick layer of red frosting. 

Elmo cookies sesame street

Now take some of your Wilton candy eye pieces and place 2 on each of your cookies to form your Elmo cookies eyes. 

Now place a butterscotch candy under each set of the eyes to form the cutest little Elmo cookies!

Super easy and super cute. 

Elmo cookies

And I’m sure your kids will love these decorated Elmo sugar cookies too!

elmo sugar cookies decorated with frosting

elmo sugar cookies decorated with frosting

Cute & Super Easy Elmo Cookies

Prep Time: 20 minutes
Active Time: 5 minutes
Total Time: 25 minutes

The cute and easy to decorate Elmo cookies are sure to be a hit at your sesame street or Elmo themed birthday!


  • Large Wilton Candy Eyes
  • Sugar Cookies
  • Red Frosting
  • Butter Scotch Hard Candies


  1. Make or buy your sugar cookeis.
  2. Using your red frosting, frost each of your sugar cookies.
  3. Now place two candy eyes on each cookie to form Elmo's eyes.
  4. Now take one Butter Scotch hard candy and place it on your cookie to create Elmo’s nose.
  5. Serve your Elmo cookies and watch the joy!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *